And yes, getting the omega-3/omega-6 balance right is crucial, but often overlooked. Glad you’re on top of it! (And yet not at all surprised.) π Let’s hear it for hemp seeds!
]]>In defense of my position, I was also referring to Dr. George Jelinek’s excellent overview of the research about diet and MS in his first book Overcoming Multiple Sclerosis. He was an editor for a medical journal as well as being still a practicing medical doctor himself, and also has MS (and so did his mother), and his own diet is a more strict version of Dr. Swank’s. He details how double blind randomized controlled studies are now done, and how when Dr. Swank started his study this technique was not in use, and thus has allowed other medical folks to debunk its amazing results over time. (Amazingly, venues like the MS Society do not endorse Dr. Swank’s work, or any dietary approach. I was also obliquely addressing that.) But Dr. Jelinek defends the veracity of the findings nonetheless in expert fashion. It’s a great read, and I highly recommend it. Ultimately, I’m with him and with Dr. Swank on how to best manage the MS–with the added stubbornness that I take no meds. And yes, you are correct, the study at OHSU done with the McDougall program showed no reduction in lesions or progression, though patients reported having more energy, less fatigue, and feeling better overall. There may have been some design flaws in that study and it didn’t go on for very long either. So that’s why, even though I feel better when I don’t use oil, and so I don’t use it, I DO make sure I have some vegan form of the healthy fats recommended in small amounts every day, which is something Dr. McDougall doesn’t really emphasize or say is necessary. As you know, the hemp hearts are a naturally perfectly balanced and easily assimiliated source of omega 3s and 6s and that really seems to work for me, so I have some every day. Wow, that was a mouthful, so to speak!! Hahaha. Hope it helps in some way. π xo
ps: rather easy to be a great mom when I have such a great son π thanks π
]]>Also, I don’t know of any research contradicting Dr. Swank’s findings. Has he been debunked in some way? I know Dr. McDougall published a study with relatively null findings recently, but I think that Dr. Swank’s data still stands, even if it is older? If not, let me know so I can read up!
And kudos to your son for helping out with the house. You’re a great mom to make him cookies in return–with homemade “fake” chocolate chips, no less. (Which I really can’t wait to try–love the hempseed idea!)
]]>